Cainiac 2012 · campaign history and tax ideas ✦

Campaign history and tax policy

Herman Cain’s 999 plan: what it was, and the tax debate it still stands for.

In the race for the 2012 Republican presidential nomination, businessman Herman Cain built his campaign around three numbers. The Herman Cain 999 plan promised to replace most federal taxes with three simple 9 percent taxes.

The plan is long gone, but the questions it raised about flat taxes and sales taxes come back in nearly every tax debate. This page covers both.

What the Herman Cain 999 plan proposed

Three taxes in place of five.

The plan would have abolished the individual income tax, corporate income tax, payroll tax and estate and gift tax, replacing them with a 9 percent national sales tax, a 9 percent business flat tax and a 9 percent individual flat tax.

Cain, a former chief executive of Godfather’s Pizza, presented it as simple and easy to remember, and it helped lift him to the front of the Republican field in the autumn of 2011. Reporting at the time also described it as a middle step towards replacing income taxes entirely with a national sales tax.

What independent analysts found

Simple rates, uneven results.

The Tax Policy Center, a joint project of the Urban Institute and the Brookings Institution, analysed the plan in October 2011. It broadly agreed the plan could raise about as much revenue as the existing system, but estimated that about 84 percent of households would pay more, while households earning over $200,000 would on average pay less.

Cain’s campaign disputed the findings and later added exemptions for people in poverty and “Opportunity Zones”, which the first analysis did not include. The campaign ended in December 2011 for reasons unrelated to the plan.

Flat tax: the idea behind one of the 9s

One rate for everyone.

Flat tax arguments
Supporters sayCritics say
Simpler to file and harder to gameA single rate takes a larger share of income from lower earners once deductions disappear
Lower top rates encourage work and investmentRevenue often falls unless the rate is set higher than advertised
Fewer special deductions means less lobbyingMany “loopholes” are popular, such as those for mortgages and charity

National sales tax: the idea behind the other 9

Taxing spending instead of income.

A national sales tax taxes what people spend rather than what they earn. Supporters argue it rewards saving and reaches people who avoid income tax. Critics point out that lower-income households spend almost all of their income, so a flat sales tax takes a larger share of their income unless it comes with rebates or exemptions. Most countries that tax consumption heavily use a value-added tax (VAT), collected in stages along the supply chain, rather than a single retail sales tax.

  1. Look at the full package. Rates matter less than what is taxed and what is exempt.
  2. Ask who pays at each income level. Distribution tables from independent analysts answer this.
  3. Check the revenue claim. A plan that loses revenue needs spending cuts or borrowing to balance.

Sources and further reading

Where the facts on this page come from.

External reference · wikipedia.org

Flat tax ↗

Definitions, arguments and examples.